BBC News – Compensation to Guantanamo detainees ‘was necessary’

15
Vote


Justice Secretary Ken Clarke said the settlement was confidential – but necessary to avoid a legal battle which could have cost up to £50m.

The men, 12 of whom had launched damages claims, allege that London knew or was complicit in their treatment in the wake of the 9/11 attacks.

The heads of both MI5 and MI6, who were being sued, welcomed the settlement.

The coalition government made clear in the summer that it wanted to avoid a massive court case which would also have put the British secret intelligence services under the spotlight.

Prime Minister David Cameron offered to enter settlement talks with six men seeking damages. Those talks were extended to other men and the BBC understands that one of those who settled is Shaker Aamer, who is still detained in Guantanamo Bay.

In his statement, Mr Clarke said: “I can today inform the House that the government has agreed a mediated settlement of the civil damages claims brought by detainees held at Guantanamo Bay.
Continue reading the main story
Analysis
image of Dominic Casciani Dominic Casciani BBC News home affairs correspondent

The government has resisted this legal claim tooth and nail. The court hearings became an exhausting battle of legal wits, as massed benches of government lawyers refused to give ground.

So why settle, given critics will inevitably accuse ministers of a cover-up? The decision should come as no surprise.

The Court of Appeal rejected ministers’ pleas to hear secret evidence in closed courts and the drip-drip of secret material from MI5 and MI6s vaults could have become a flood.

Settling the case therefore achieves the government’s greater aim.

It paves the way for a judge-led inquiry into complicity and rendition. That inquiry will soon go about its business but the main accusers won’t be appearing in public demanding the exposure of a secret paper trail from Afghanistan to government offices in London.

Paying out millions looks bad, but ministers know that exposing state secrets is worse still.

* Profiles: Guantanamo Bay Britons

“The details of that settlement have been made subject to a legally binding confidentiality agreement. They have been reported in confidence to the Chairman of the Intelligence and Security Committee, and to the National Audit Office. No admissions of culpability have been made in settling these cases.

“The alternative to any payments made would have been protracted and extremely expensive litigation in an uncertain legal environment in which the government could not be certain that it would be able to defend Departments and the Security and Intelligence Agencies without compromising national security.

“This cost was estimated at approximately £30-50m over 3-5 years and in our view there could have been no inquiry until that litigation had been resolved.”

In a statement issued on their behalf, the heads of both MI5 and MI6 welcomed the deal.

“Further to the Lord Chancellor’s statement in the house on 16 November, Chief of SIS [Secret Intelligence Service], Sir John Sawers and Director General of the Security Service, Jonathan Evans, welcome the conclusion to the mediation which allows the agencies to concentrate on protecting national security,” said the statement.

‘Confidence eroded’

Mr Clarke told the Commons that there was a risk that public confidence in the UK’s adherence to human rights was being eroded, including the rules governing the security and intelligence agencies.
Guantanamo Bay prisoners File pic: 2002 The controversial Guantanamo Bay camp was run by US forces

The police are still investigating allegations made by some of the detainees – but Mr Clarke said that once those inquiries were complete, a judge-led inquiry could begin.

Bisher al-Rawi, Jamil el Banna, Richard Belmar, Omar Deghayes, Binyam Mohamed and Martin Mubanga had led a High Court case against five government departments, including MI5 and MI6.

They had claimed that officials in London were complicit in their transfer to Guantanamo Bay and should have prevented it and their alleged ill treatment.

In May, the Court of Appeal ruled that the government could not rely on secret evidence to defend itself against the six cases, saying allegations of wrongdoing had to be heard in public.

Since then, more than 60 government lawyers and officials have been sifting through an estimated 500,000 documents at a secret location.
Continue reading the main story
“Start Quote

Sources close to the Pentagon believe there will be two private reactions – one coming from the heart, the other the head. The initial reaction may be one of annoyance and profound embarrassment… but on reflection it will be seen as a rational decision ”

End Quote BBC North America Editor Mark Mardell

* BBC – Mark Mardell’s America

The Intelligence and Security Committee and the National Audit Office have been briefed about the payments, but nothing will be made public, including how much each detainee has received.

As in common in such settlements, the government has not admitted liability – and the claimants have not withdrawn their allegations.

Shadow justice secretary Sadiq Khan asked for details of the cost of the payments, saying it was in the “public interest” to know the sums involved.

But Mr Clarke told him the settlement “could be reopened if either side started breaking the confidentiality”.

Shami Chakrabarti, director of human rights group Liberty, said: “This settlement could bring a broader inquiry and the end of the torture scandal a little bit closer.

“But if the slow, morale-sapping bleed of revelation and litigation is to end, the Gibson process must have all the power and authority of a court.

“It must distinguish between national security and embarrassment; between clean up and cover up.”
[Story Source] [Contest win Rs 1000-100,000 now]

This post was submitted by Chinmaya Nayak.

Related Posts
BBC News – Monkey HIV vaccine ‘effective’, say researchers

BBC News – Monkey HIV vaccine ‘effective’, say researchers

A new vaccine can protect macaques against the monkey equivalent of HIV and could provide a fresh approach to an HIV vaccine, a study suggests.US researchers say the vac...
 Ozone hole has dried Australia, says study

Ozone hole has dried Australia, says study

The Antarctic ozone hole is about one-third to blame for Australia's recent series of droughts, say scientists.Writing in the journal Science, they conclude that the hole has shifted wind and rainf...
BBC News – Taliban impostor ‘dupes Afghans and vanishes with cash’

BBC News – Taliban impostor ‘dupes Afghans and vanishes with cash’

An impostor posing as a leading Taliban negotiator held secret talks with Afghan officials, report US media.The Afghans thought they were dealing with Mullah Akhtar Mohammed Mansour, a top Taliban com...
Compensation to Guantanamo detainees ‘was necessary’

Compensation to Guantanamo detainees ‘was necessary’

Justice Secretary Ken Clarke said the settlement was confidential - but necessary to avoid a legal battle which could have cost up to £50m.The men, 12 of whom had launched damages claims, allege that ...
 BBC Red Button, an interactive TV service needs to lower distribution cost

BBC Red Button, an interactive TV service needs to lower distribution cost

BBC needs to reduce the distribution cost on its Red Button services. A BBC Trust review has ended in a statement that the Red Button services by the same which is mostly preferred by UK has the reduc...
BBC iPlayer to be available to BT Vision subscribers

BBC iPlayer to be available to BT Vision subscribers

The success of the BBC iPlayer on Virgin Media's cable service as well as on games consoles PS3 and Wii have already proved that consumers are eager to access catch-up TV on their traditional TV sets....

Leave a Reply

 
We will keep You Updated...
Get Free Email Newsletter from VoteUpIndia Sign up for our free email newsletter. (Help?)
Read latest headlines in your favorite news reader
Follow VoteUpIndia  on Twitter Become a VoteUpIndia Fan on Facebook Subscribe to VoteUpIndia in Google Reader Add VoteUpIndia  to My Yahoo Add VoteUpIndia  to Netvibes Subscribe to Free Techie Buzz RSS Feed
Sponsored Links
Advertisements
Featured Video
Amazon
Best Storytellers
Powered by Authors Widget
Recent Posts

McDonald's Suspends Employee, Probes Child's Eviction From Pune Outlet

PUNE: After reports emerged that an eight-year-old destitute child was thrown out of an outlet of...

Why Arjun Made a Humble Request to Cast Sonakshi in Tevar

It's all about wearing your Tevar, this new year. Arjun Kapoor looked dapper at the initial promotions...

5 things Modi needs to do ASAP, after Bihar loss

It's not correct to transpose the outcome from a state election as a referendum on the central government,...

Sehwag's half century in All Star tournament.

The first match has been really special. We thoroughly enjoyed being here. New York, you were brilliant....

Bihar Defeat May Lead to Silent Rebellion in BJP Against PM, Amit Shah: Arun Shourie to NDTV

NEW DELHI: In the aftermath of the BJP's debacle in Bihar, Arun Shourie, one time admirer of Narendra...

Court Refuses to Stop Gillette Razor Ad Starring Deepika Padukone

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has refused to stop a Gillette razor advertisement starring Deepika...

Bigg Boss 9: Roopal Tyagi voted out of the house

TV actor Roopal Tyagi was evicted from reality show Bigg Boss on Sunday’s episode. Roopal is the...
Recent Comments
How i can submit my story...? and where i can see the staus of votes for this?
IFFI lose its art value,so it became lose it commercial value
Dear sir I am sending an article which is based on true story and needs your help to lime light such incidents which never come in
Thanks for the interesting article. Great Post. Keep it up
It is indeed heartening to learn that LSE, the world leader in higher education, will join hands with the most admired Reliance Foun
Tag Cloud